← Back to blog

Nonprofit Payroll Taxes in California: What You Owe in 2026

October 21, 2026
Nonprofit Payroll Taxes in California: What You Owe in 2026

A 501(c)(3) in California is exempt from federal unemployment tax (FUTA), but it is not exempt from payroll taxes in general. You still withhold and pay federal income tax and FICA. At the state level, most nonprofits also owe Unemployment Insurance (UI), Employment Training Tax (ETT), State Disability Insurance (SDI) withholding and Personal Income Tax (PIT) withholding. The one real choice is how you finance UI: pay a tax rate like any other employer, or reimburse the state for benefits actually paid.

This guide walks through each obligation, the 2026 rates, the reimbursable method and the mistakes we see new nonprofit employers make.

Glendale Payroll
Keep Nonprofit Payroll Compliant
Glendale Payroll provides payroll processing and compliance services for California businesses, with dedicated payroll professionals and a comprehensive payroll audit.
Explore payroll services

TL;DR

  • Tax-exempt status does not remove payroll tax duties. The IRS states that exempt organizations with employees must withhold federal income tax and pay Social Security and Medicare taxes.
  • 501(c)(3) organizations are exempt from FUTA, but California UI, ETT, SDI and PIT still generally apply.
  • For UI, a 501(c)(3) can pay the standard rate (3.4% for new employers) or choose the reimbursable method, which bills you for actual benefits paid and typically binds you for five calendar years.
  • Board members and officers can be personally liable if withheld taxes are not paid over. Treat payroll deposits as a board-level control.
  • Register with the EDD before your first payday and calendar every deposit and filing deadline.

Table of Contents

Federal payroll taxes for nonprofits

Federal rules come first because they apply to every nonprofit with employees, whatever its size.

What still applies

According to the IRS guidance on employment taxes for exempt organizations, a tax-exempt organization with employees is responsible for federal income tax withholding and for Social Security and Medicare taxes. Exemption from income tax on the organization's own earnings has nothing to do with the tax you withhold from employee wages.

For 2026, the EDD's DE 201 publication lists the Social Security rate at 6.2% for both employer and employee, up to a wage base of $184,500. The Medicare rate is 1.45% for each, with no wage base limit.

In practice, each pay period you:

  1. Withhold federal income tax based on each employee's Form W-4.
  2. Withhold the employee's share of Social Security and Medicare.
  3. Add the matching employer share.
  4. Deposit the total on your IRS deposit schedule and report it on your quarterly return.

The IRS Publication 15 (Circular E) is the reference for deposit rules and withholding tables.

The FUTA exemption

Organizations recognized under Section 501(c)(3) are exempt from FUTA, per the same IRS page. This is the one federal payroll tax a 501(c)(3) can skip. It does not extend to other employment taxes. If you want to see how federal and state unemployment taxes compare for ordinary employers, our breakdown of FUTA vs. SUTA in California covers it.

A few worker categories have special treatment, such as certain ministers and church employees. The IRS lists them on its page on employment tax exceptions and exclusions for exempt organizations. If you employ clergy, confirm their status before you decide what to withhold.

California payroll taxes for nonprofits

The state side is where most new nonprofit employers get caught. The EDD's FAQ says most nonprofit organizations need to pay UI, ETT, SDI and PIT. The EDD's nonprofit and public entities guide (DE 231NP) makes the same point: nonprofit entities are subject to these state taxes.

The four state taxes at a glance

TaxWho pays2026 figureNotes
Unemployment Insurance (UI)Employer3.4% for new employersTaxable wage limit of $7,000 per employee per year. Nonprofits can elect reimbursement instead.
Employment Training Tax (ETT)Employer0.1%Same $7,000 limit. Applies to employers with a positive UI reserve balance.
State Disability Insurance (SDI)Employee, withheld by you1.3%No wage ceiling since 2024. Funds disability and Paid Family Leave.
Personal Income Tax (PIT)Employee, withheld by youPer withholding tablesYou withhold and remit it.

The UI, ETT and SDI figures come from the EDD's tax-rated employer page, which also confirms that new employers receive the 3.4% UI rate for two to three years. The 2026 UI rate schedule is F+, with rates from 1.5% to 6.2% once your experience rating applies.

One caution on sources: some third-party pages still show older or incorrect SDI rates. Check the EDD's own figures before you set up payroll.

The four state taxes at a glance — overview diagram

A worked example

Suppose a youth services nonprofit has four employees, each earning more than $7,000 a year, and elects the standard UI method as a new employer.

  • UI: 3.4% of $7,000 is $238 per employee, or $952 a year for four.
  • ETT: 0.1% of $7,000 is $7 per employee, or $28 for four.

Those are the employer-paid state unemployment costs for the year, assuming a positive reserve balance and ignoring any later rate change. SDI and PIT are withheld from employee wages and passed through, so they are not a cost to the organization, though they reduce take-home pay and affect how you explain compensation to staff.

Exempt from federal, not from California

The most common pitfall is assuming federal 501(c)(3) status carries over. It does not. The EDD notes that even where some religious workers are excluded from UI or SDI, their wages are typically still subject to PIT withholding and reporting, unless a specific exemption for ministers applies. For the full explanation, see the EDD payroll taxes FAQ.

State exemption status also depends on staying in good standing. The Franchise Tax Board explains that nonprofits must keep up annual filing requirements with several agencies, including the Attorney General's office and the Secretary of State. Lapses there can put state-level exemptions at risk.

Choosing how to finance Unemployment Insurance

This is the decision that makes nonprofit payroll different from a for-profit business. Under the EDD's reimbursable method rules, a 501(c)(3) can choose between two options.

Option 1: The tax-rated (experience rating) method

You pay UI tax on the first $7,000 of each employee's wages, like a commercial employer. New employers start at 3.4%. After that, your rate follows your own history of benefit charges. Costs are predictable and you can budget them as a fixed percentage of payroll.

Option 2: The reimbursable method

You pay nothing in UI tax. When a former employee collects UI benefits, the EDD bills you for the actual dollars paid. The election is made on form DE 1SNP, which is returned to the EDD's Specialized Coverage Unit.

Comparing the two

FactorTax-ratedReimbursable
What you payA percentage of the first $7,000 per employeeActual benefits paid to your former employees
Budget certaintyHighLow: depends on separations
Best fitGrowing teams, higher turnover, grant-funded programs with uncertain end datesStable teams with very low turnover and cash reserves
RiskRate may rise with claimsA layoff or several departures can produce a large bill
CommitmentStandardTypically five full calendar years

Two points deserve emphasis. First, the reimbursable method is a financing choice, not a tax exemption. Second, the EDD generally expects you to stay on it for five full calendar years, and it can end the election if you fall behind on reimbursement payments. If your funding depends on a grant that might not renew, a sudden program closure could send a cluster of claims to your organization at once.

Before electing, ask your board or finance committee to model a worst case: what if your three highest-paid employees were laid off in the same quarter? If you cannot absorb that cost from reserves, the tax-rated method is usually the safer choice. A CPA who works with nonprofits should confirm the numbers for your situation.

Registering and reporting in California

A new nonprofit employer should complete these steps before the first payroll:

  1. Get an EIN from the IRS if you do not have one.
  2. Register for an EDD employer account. This is how you receive your account number and UI rate. Our team handles EDD account setup for clients.
  3. Decide your UI method and file DE 1SNP if you choose reimbursement.
  4. Collect Forms W-4 and DE 4 from each employee for federal and state withholding.
  5. Report new hires to the EDD.
  6. Set your deposit and filing calendar. Our California payroll tax calendar lists the EDD and IRS deadlines in one place.
  7. Prepare W-2s at year end and file them on time.

If you also run fundraising events or hire seasonal help, treat those workers carefully. Misclassifying employees as contractors creates the same exposure for a nonprofit as for any employer. Our guide to startup payroll tax obligations covers the basics for first-time employers, and most of it applies to a new nonprofit too.

Personal liability for board members and officers

Nonprofit leaders often assume the corporate form shields them. For withheld payroll taxes, it may not. The IRS describes the Trust Fund Recovery Penalty as an assessment that can fall on any responsible person who willfully fails to collect, account for or pay over withheld income and employment taxes. That can include officers and, in some cases, board members. The details are on the IRS exempt organization employment tax page.

Practical controls that reduce the risk:

  • Make payroll tax deposits a standing item in treasurer or finance committee reports.
  • Never use withheld tax money to cover a cash shortfall, even briefly.
  • Require a second person to review deposit confirmations.
  • Keep payroll records separate from general bookkeeping so a staff change does not leave gaps.

Staying current with California law

Rates and rules change every year. The UI schedule, the SDI rate and the wage base figures above are all 2026 numbers, and the 2025 values were different. Boards and executive directors who want advance notice of new payroll or employment bills can follow them through a legislative tracker such as OneGov's California bill tracking, which also helps with the broader compliance picture for nonprofits. For payroll-specific changes, our 2026 California payroll tax updates page summarizes what employers need to act on.

Our perspective: why nonprofits get payroll compliance wrong

We work with small employers across Glendale, Burbank, Pasadena and Greater Los Angeles, and the pattern with nonprofits is consistent. The organization is run by people who care about the mission, and payroll gets handled by whoever is available. The tax status creates a false sense of safety.

Three things we tell every nonprofit client:

  • Exempt does not mean excused. Federal withholding, FICA, California UI, ETT, SDI and PIT all need to be right from the first paycheck.
  • The UI election deserves a board discussion. Reimbursement can look attractive on paper, but it moves risk from the state to your budget. We would rather you choose it deliberately than discover it after a layoff.
  • Errors are expensive and avoidable. Late deposits and misreported wages draw penalties. A payroll audit before a problem surfaces costs far less than a notice after.

That is why we employ dedicated payroll professionals instead of a call center, and why every engagement begins with a free comprehensive payroll audit that looks for compliance risks in your current setup. If you want to know what an EDD review would look for, start with our EDD audit preparation checklist.

— Glendale Payroll Staff

How Glendale Payroll can help

We handle payroll processing, direct deposit, federal and California payroll tax filing, new hire reporting, W-2 preparation and EDD account setup for small organizations. Pricing is published: $105 per month per company, $12 per month per employee, and a one-time $100 setup fee. For a nonprofit with five employees, that works out to $165 per month after setup ($105 plus five times $12). See the full list on our services page, or contact us to schedule your free payroll audit.

FAQ

Do California nonprofits pay unemployment tax?

Most do. A 501(c)(3) is exempt from federal FUTA, but California requires nonprofits to be covered for UI. You either pay the standard UI rate (3.4% for new employers in 2026) on the first $7,000 per employee, or elect to reimburse the EDD for benefits paid to former employees.

Do nonprofits have to withhold California income tax and SDI?

Generally yes. The EDD says most nonprofits must pay UI, ETT and SDI and must withhold PIT. SDI is withheld from employee wages at 1.3% in 2026 with no wage cap. Certain religious workers have special rules, so confirm their status with the EDD before you skip any withholding.

Can a nonprofit switch back after choosing the reimbursable method?

Not easily. The EDD typically requires nonprofits to remain on the reimbursable method for five full calendar years, and it can terminate the election if you become delinquent on reimbursement payments. Review the EDD reimbursable method page and your finances before you file.

Can board members be personally liable for unpaid payroll taxes?

They can be. The IRS may assess the Trust Fund Recovery Penalty against any responsible person who willfully fails to pay over withheld taxes. If you serve on a board, ask for regular confirmation that deposits are made on time, and speak with a CPA or tax attorney about your own exposure.

Sources