← Back to blog

Payroll Rounding Rules in California: What Employers Can Do

October 29, 2026
Payroll Rounding Rules in California: What Employers Can Do

California has not banned time rounding outright, but the room for it is shrinking. Courts have long accepted a rounding policy that is neutral on its face and in practice, and they have rejected rounding of meal-period punches. The California Supreme Court is now reviewing whether neutral rounding of ordinary work time is allowed at all when your system captures exact minutes. If you run payroll for nonexempt employees, the safest practice is to pay the minutes your employees actually work.

Glendale Payroll
Keep California Payroll Compliant
Glendale Payroll provides payroll processing and compliance support, with dedicated payroll professionals and a comprehensive audit to help identify risks.
Explore payroll support

TL;DR

  • Rounding is lawful in California only if it is neutral on its face, applied neutrally, and does not underpay employees over time.
  • You may never round meal-period punches. The California Supreme Court settled that in Donohue v. AMN Services (2021).
  • The Supreme Court is reviewing Camp v. Home Depot, which asks whether neutral rounding survives when electronic timekeeping records exact minutes.
  • The federal "seven-minute rule" is a permitted federal method, not a California safe harbor.
  • The lowest-risk approach: record exact punches, pay exact time, and audit your timekeeping data regularly.

Table of Contents

What Rounding Means in Payroll

Time rounding means adjusting an employee's recorded start and stop times to a set increment, such as the nearest five minutes, tenth of an hour or quarter hour, before wages are calculated. A punch at 8:03 becomes 8:00. A punch out at 5:06 becomes 5:00. Over a pay period, the adjustments can favor the employee, favor the employer, or cancel out.

Rounding began as a convenience for paper cards and mechanical clocks. Federal regulation 29 C.F.R. § 785.48(b) permits rounding to the nearest five minutes, one-tenth of an hour or quarter hour, as long as it averages out so employees are paid for all the time they work. California courts have borrowed that standard for decades.

The issue today is that modern timekeeping software records every punch to the second. A rounding step is now a choice, not a technical necessity, and courts have started to ask why you would discard recorded minutes.

The Standard California Courts Have Applied

The leading appellate decision is Silva v. See's Candy Shops (2017). The court held that an employer may use a rounding policy if it is fair and neutral on its face and does not, over time, result in a failure to pay employees properly for all time worked. The Ninth Circuit followed that approach and noted that an employer does not have to break even on every single shift, only avoid systematic underpayment over time.

CalChamber's HRCalifornia guidance describes the same test: a rounding policy must be neutral on its face and in practice and must not, over time, leave employees uncompensated for time worked. Three questions follow from that test:

  1. Is the rule neutral on its face? Rounding to the nearest quarter hour passes. A rule that only rounds punch-ins forward, or only rounds down, does not.
  2. Is it applied neutrally? The same rule must apply to every employee and every shift. A supervisor who adjusts punches only when employees clock in early fails this step.
  3. Does it underpay over time? Your data, not your policy wording, answers this. If rounding loses employees minutes across a quarter, the policy fails, however neutral it looks.

A worked example

Suppose you round to the nearest quarter hour. An employee clocks in at 7:56 (rounded to 8:00, losing 4 minutes of paid time) and out at 4:07 (rounded to 4:00, losing 7 minutes). That shift lost 11 minutes. Another employee clocks in at 8:05 (rounded to 8:00, gaining 5 minutes) and out at 4:08 (rounded to 4:15, gaining 7 minutes).

Quarter-hour rounding losses and gains compared

On paper, both outcomes are "neutral." In practice, if your workforce tends to arrive early and stay late to finish tasks, the rounding will lean against employees. That pattern is what plaintiffs look for in the time data.

Meal Periods: Rounding Is Not Allowed

This part of the law is settled. In Donohue v. AMN Services, LLC, the California Supreme Court held that employers cannot round time punches in the meal-period context, because rounding is incompatible with the strict, time-sensitive requirements of California meal-period law.

The same decision held that time records showing noncompliant meal periods raise a rebuttable presumption of a meal-period violation, and that presumption can be applied even at summary judgment. Put simply, if your records show a 27-minute lunch, or a lunch that started after the end of the fifth hour, you start from a weak position.

What this means for your payroll:

  • Do not apply rounding to punches that start or end a meal period.
  • Configure your time clock so meal punches are recorded exactly.
  • Review reports of short, late or missing meal periods and confirm that premium pay was paid where owed.

For a broader view of the daily requirements, see our guide to California timekeeping requirements for employers.

The Camp v. Home Depot Case

In October 2022, the Sixth District Court of Appeal decided Camp v. Home Depot U.S.A., Inc. Home Depot rounded total shift time: seven minutes or less rounded down and eight minutes or more rounded up to the nearest quarter hour. The court found a triable issue about unpaid wages, in large part because the company's system could capture the exact minutes worked. The court of appeal's decision says an employer that can capture exact time must pay for it.

The California Supreme Court granted review. According to its list of pending civil issues, the question is whether employers may use neutral time-rounding practices to calculate work time for payroll purposes. Commentary on the court's docket showed that oral argument had not yet been calendared as of spring 2026. Check the California Supreme Court's website for the current status before you set or change a policy.

What this means while the case is pending

Until the court rules, See's Candy remains the framework many employers rely on, but you should treat it as a defense you may have to prove, not a guarantee. If the Supreme Court affirms Camp, rounding will be hard to defend wherever your system records exact punches. If it reverses, neutral rounding will survive, but only if your data shows it does not shortchange employees.

Either outcome points the same way for an employer with electronic timekeeping: exact time has no legal downside, and rounding carries a litigation risk.

The Federal Seven-Minute Rule Is Not a California Safe Harbor

Many employers hear about a "7-minute rule" and assume it is a legal standard. It is a way of applying the federal quarter-hour option: punches within seven minutes after the quarter hour round down, and punches at eight minutes or more round up. The federal regulation allows rounding if it averages out. It does not guarantee that any specific method is lawful.

In California, three things limit the rule:

  • It cannot be applied to meal-period punches.
  • It must produce neutral results in your actual data.
  • With electronic timekeeping, it faces the Camp challenge described above.

We also see websites claiming that California requires rounding to the nearest five minutes. That is not accurate. California does not require rounding. Federal rules permit certain increments, and California courts allow rounding only under the neutrality standard.

Grace Periods and Early Punches

Rounding problems often hide in related practices:

  • Grace periods. A policy that gives employees a few minutes after the start time before they are marked late is a discipline rule. It cannot be used to avoid paying for minutes actually worked.
  • Early punch-ins. If an employee punches in 10 minutes early and begins working, those minutes are work time. If the employee is waiting and not working, document it and make sure the employee is free from duty.
  • Auto-deducted lunches. A system that deducts 30 minutes regardless of the actual punch conflicts with the Donohue presumption when the employee did not take a compliant break.
  • Pre-shift and post-shift tasks. Security checks, opening and closing duties and equipment setup count when they are required and performed while under your control.

See our guides to reporting time pay and travel time pay for two more areas where small timing differences become wage claims.

Why Rounding Errors Become Large Liabilities

A few unpaid minutes seem harmless. They are not, for three reasons.

They scale. Four minutes lost per shift for 20 employees across a year is a large number of unpaid hours. Employers owe wages for every shift in the claim period.

They can trigger overtime and minimum wage claims. The Camp plaintiffs alleged unpaid minimum and overtime wages under the Labor Code from rounding, and brought the case as a putative class action. Unpaid minutes can push a week over an overtime threshold. Our California overtime rules guide explains the daily and weekly thresholds.

They are visible in your own data. Time records are discoverable. A plaintiff's expert can compare raw punches to paid time across every employee and find the pattern.

Recordkeeping Requirements That Support Your Position

California Labor Code Section 1174 requires employers to keep accurate records of nonexempt employees' work time showing when each work period and meal period begins and ends, and total daily hours. The records must be properly dated and kept in indelible or equivalent form. CalChamber's guidance recommends keeping payroll records for at least four years, advises auditing timekeeping records regularly, and says the best practice is not to round time entries at all.

A practical retention approach:

  • Keep raw punch data, not only the rounded or approved totals.
  • Keep edits with the date, the person who made them and the reason.
  • Keep signed timesheet corrections from employees.
  • Keep a copy of the policy in force for each period.

How to Move Away From Rounding: A Step-by-Step Plan

  1. Find out whether you round. Check your time clock settings, your payroll software's import rules and any manual spreadsheet steps. Many employers round without knowing, because a default setting does it.
  2. Pull a sample. Take 3 to 6 months of raw punches and compare them with paid hours for 10 or more employees. Note the net minutes gained or lost.
  3. Turn off rounding on meal punches immediately. This is the one area where no defense exists.
  4. Switch to exact-minute pay for work time. Most modern systems pay to the minute or to the hundredth of an hour at no extra cost.
  5. Update your handbook. State that employees are paid for all time worked, must record their time accurately, and must report errors.
  6. Audit quarterly. Check for missing meal punches, early punch-ins, manual edits and repeated patterns by supervisor.
  7. Review back pay exposure with counsel. If your sample shows past underpayment, speak with an employment attorney before deciding how to correct it.

If you are choosing a system, look at time tracking software options that record exact time and let you review hours by role and project. Whatever you pick, confirm that it records punches without rounding and that it exports raw data to payroll.

Our Perspective

We review payroll records for small employers across Glendale, Burbank, Pasadena and Greater Los Angeles, and rounding is one of the problems we most often find by accident. It is rarely a deliberate policy. It is a setting someone chose years ago, a feature of a punch clock, or an import rule in a payroll platform. Nobody revisits it until a wage claim arrives.

Our advice is simple. Pay exact minutes. The cost of paying a few extra minutes in an average week is small and predictable. The cost of defending a class claim, or of paying back wages, penalties and interest across several years, is not. Rounding that favors you today can look like a policy you adopted to save money, and the legal framework for defending it is under review.

If you still use rounding, do it knowingly: neutral rule, no meal punches, quarterly data checks, and a written record of the results. And because wage and hour law changes through court decisions as much as through statutes, we track those developments so you do not have to read every opinion.

— Glendale Payroll Staff

Payroll Support That Keeps Time Data Clean

Payroll errors start in the hours that feed the payroll run. At Glendale Payroll, dedicated payroll professionals, not a call center, handle your payroll processing, federal and California tax filing, direct deposit, W-2 preparation, new hire reporting and EDD account setup. Each engagement includes a free comprehensive payroll audit, which is a good moment to check how your hours are captured and paid.

Our published pricing is $105 per month per company plus $12 per employee per month, with a one-time setup fee of $100. For a team of 10, that works out to $225 per month after setup. See the full details on our pricing page or review our payroll services.

Glendale Payroll

To see how your current process measures up, start with our guide to a payroll process review, then request your free audit.

A rounding review often exposes neighboring issues. These are the ones we check most:

FAQ

Sometimes. California courts have allowed rounding that is neutral on its face, applied neutrally, and does not underpay employees over time. That framework is under review in Camp v. Home Depot, so the risk is higher if your system records exact minutes. Rounding of meal-period punches is not allowed under any circumstances.

Can I use the 7-minute rule in California?

Only as a form of quarter-hour rounding, and only if it meets California's neutrality test and is not applied to meal punches. It is a federal-style method, not a protected California standard. Paying exact minutes avoids the question.

Can employers round meal break punches?

No. The California Supreme Court held in Donohue v. AMN Services that rounding meal-period punches is not permitted. Records showing a short or late meal period create a presumption of a violation.

What can an employee do if rounding causes unpaid wages?

An employee can bring a claim for unpaid minimum and overtime wages under the Labor Code, individually or as part of a class action, as the plaintiff did in Camp. An employer facing this situation should contact an employment attorney.

How long should I keep time records?

CalChamber's guidance recommends at least four years for payroll records. Keep the raw punch data, not only the rounded totals, so you can show what was recorded and what was paid.

Sources